Menu

Top Shelf Cookies & Treats Menu

Handmade Treats Baked to Order

Request Estimate

Hero Request Form

Indulge in the Sweetest Delights at Top Shelf Cookies & Treats

Craving something sweet? You're in the right place! At Top Shelf Cookies & Treats, we've got a mouthwatering array of homemade cookies and treats that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.  From our delectable buttercream icing that's simply irresistible to chewy chocolate brownies, we've got something for everyone. Our chocolate chip cookie recipe, perfected over two decades, is a crowd favorite. And did we mention everything is made fresh daily?


As one sweet customer put it, “My favorite is whichever one I am eating at the moment!” 


Call to place your order.

Our Menu

Cookies

Classic Chocolate Chip

The name says it all. This is our “O.G.” and what we are most popular for. 

Frosted Sugar Cookies

Soft and tender sugar cookies rolled, cut, and baked to perfection. Decorated and topped with our famous creamy frosting. Seriously, you could put our frosting on a shoelace and be like, “That is the best shoelace I’ve ever eaten!” 


See the Custom Sugar Cookies page for information on cookies cut and decorated specifically for your theme or event. 

Triple Chocolate Chip

Chocolate three ways. A chocolate chocolate chip cookie. For true chocolate lovers only.

M&M

Nostalgic for that candy cookie you had as a kid? Sugar & butter are melted together to create this chewy, soft cookie with M&Ms sprinkled throughout.

Snickerdoodle

Satisfyingly chewy with crispy edges for irresistible textural contrast.

Brown Sugar

Browned butter, brown sugar, and lots of vanilla. Yum!

Peanut Butter JuJu

Imagine the best peanut butter cookie you’ve ever had…and make it better! Our very own Julia crafted this amazing wonder, and we can’t wait for you to try it!


**Add chocolate chips, $2  


**Add chopped peanut butter cups, $3


**Need these gluten-free? Just ask…no upcharge!


No-Bake

Oatmeal, peanut butter, and chocolate – yes, please!

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut

Our “O.G” base with white chocolate and macadamia nuts. Rich and delicious! 


**$3 upcharge from base price  


Chocolate Crinkle Cookie

A lighter chocolate cookie than our triple chocolate, rolled in our special sugar blend and baked to chocolatey perfection.

Not-Your-Grandma's Oatmeal Cookie

A dense, chewy cookie that’s not too sweet and ALWAYS made with butter!


No charge to add raisins OR chocolate chips. If you want both, there will be a $2 upcharge. 


**Substitute butterscotch chips or white chocolate chips, add $2


**Add walnuts or pecans, add $2


Treats

Scotcheroos

A rice cereal base with sugar and peanut butter topped with a generous layer of chocolate and butterscotch. 

Rice Krispy Treats

This is NOT the box recipe! We mix rice cereal with our secret ratio of marshmallows and butter for a treat so delicious you won’t believe it’s “just” rice krispy treats!


**Add Oreos and white and chocolate drizzle for $4


Brownies

Chocolate and chewy, simple and satisfying, these are thick! We recommend having ice cream handy to put on top!


**Add a generous peanut butter swirl for $3 


Cake Pops

Vanilla or chocolate cake mixed with frosting, smooshed into a ball, and dipped in white or traditional chocolate. These. Taste. Amazing. 


Of all the cookies and treats that we make in our kitchen, this is the one that we ALWAYS make extras of to eat for ourselves! 


Prices start at $30/dozen for a basic cake pop with the same color drizzle as the coating color selected. We love to customize these to coordinate with your event! 


Contact us to get the conversation and party started!

Cookie Cakes

Cookie cakes are a great way to celebrate a special person in your life! You get our famous chocolate chip cookie, ten inches wide, with a special message written in vanilla buttercream for the recipient. These are always a hit at any gathering! 


Prices start at $30 each. 

Cupcakes

Fresh vanilla or rich chocolate cupcakes by the dozen topped with a generous swirl of our famous frosting in traditional or chocolate. 


Prices start at $24/dozen. 


Call us if you want a special flavor not listed here. 

Custom Sugar Cookies

Straight talk: We use buttercream, not royal icing. It is a fact that royal icing is ridiculously gorgeous and makes some of the prettiest cookies we have ever seen. Can we confess something though? We don’t think it tastes nearly as good as our buttercream, and it sure is a whole lot more expensive! 


We decorate your custom sugar cookies with our famous buttercream because we want to make you cookies that are not only beautiful but delicious too! Check out our social media to see what we have done for our customers! 


We would love to create something beautiful and delicious for you that will keep your guests coming back for more! Call us to chat about your needs – we work with all budgets, quantities, and themes. 


Prices start at $24/dozen. 

Oatmeal Breakfast Muffins

Our family’s favorite way to start the day since 2008! We soak our oats in buttermilk for an extra-tender crumb, throw in a generous handful of chocolate chips, and bake them up hot and fresh! 


These freeze beautifully and easily heat up in the microwave for a quick way to start your day! 


$15/dozen

Cost

  • $20 for 12 freshly baked cookies or treats (one flavor)
  • $12 for six freshly baked cookies or treats (one flavor)
  • $5 for a two-pack of our chocolate chip cookies, gift-wrapped & tied with a bow
  • Minis! Want a smaller version of our full-size cookie? $14 will get you a dozen. At this time, we are not doing minis in any amount smaller than one dozen, and they must be one flavor per dozen.


There may be times when two-packs of other cookies and treats may be available. Hint: Watch our “Stories” on our socials!

Delivery

Delivery in Grand Ledge, MI is only $5. Outside of Grand Ledge? Contact us for an estimate!

How to Order

We can generally accommodate same-day requests. Either message us on our socials or you can call or text if you prefer. Once we agree on your order and pricing, we will set an agreed-upon time for you to come pick up your goodies.


Is there a baked good that you love and don’t see listed? Call us to see what we can do for you! Our social media will occasionally display items that are not on the list above, and it is possible we just haven’t had time to update our menu. 


We do our best to make ourselves available to the date and time you prefer. We LOVE seeing old friends and meeting new ones! Please note custom or large orders may require prepayment. 

How to Pay

Cash is king! In the event you don’t have it handy, we can take payment via: 


  • Check
  • Credit or debit card*


*Please note a 3.5% convenience fee will be added. 

Housekeeping Notes

Custom orders or orders over $50 will require prepayment. Thank you for your understanding. We are a small business and can’t afford the risk of people not picking up their orders. 


If you are running late to the time we agreed upon for pickup or delivery, please text us to let us know. 


If you are more than an hour late and have not notified us, you will forfeit your order. Future orders of any size will require prepayment. 


The cost for the cookies is based upon dozens fitting into one box. We may occasionally split up your order into several boxes if we deem that to be the best presentation (i.e., we don’t want to smoosh your freshly decorated sugar cookies). If you request to split up your order, there will be a $2 charge for each additional box.


Call if you have any questions.

Learn More About

Top Shelf Cookies & Treats

Located in Grand Ledge, MI, Top Shelf Cookies & Treats specializes in sugar cookies, cake pops, cupcakes, and cookie cakes. Handmade treats baked to order. Call now.

Watch Video

Play Video
Share by: