Top Shelf Cookies & Treats Menu

Handmade Treats Baked to Order

Indulge in the Sweetest Delights at Top Shelf Cookies & Treats

These are in no particular order…they are all “our favorites”, and we hope they will be yours too! As one sweet customer put it, “My favorite is whichever one I am eating at the moment!”

Everyday Cookies

1/$3 2/$5 6/$15 12/$24

Minis – $18 / dozen

* Upgraded mix-ins are endless.

Contact for quote.

Chocolate Chip

Colorful folded fabric bundles in red, green, and white, arranged in a neat grid.

Frosted Sugar

Cluster of glossy brown nuts or seeds bound together on a wooden surface

No Bakes

Oatmeal

Stack of cracked, golden-brown cookies on a white background

Peanut Butter

Cookie topped with colorful candy pieces, surrounded by scattered rainbow candies

M&M

Close-up of stacked chocolate cookies with cracked, glossy tops

Triple Chocolate

Stacked cinnamon-sugar pita chips close-up

Snickerdoodle

Tray of cracked sugar cookies cooling on a wire rack

Molasses

Lemon

Chocolate Crinkle

Toffee

Treats

Chocolate truffles with white drizzle arranged on a rustic wooden surface

Dipped PB Cookies – $3

Frosted Brownies – $6

Scotcheroos – $6

Cake Pops – $3

Rice Krispy Treats – $5

Granola Bars – $3

Sandwich Cookies – $4

DIY Cookie Kits – $26

Cupcakes

Dozens starting at $30. Contact for quote.

Cookie Cakes

Round cookie with blue and white frosting reading “Congrats Melinda” on a wooden surface

10" Round – $30*

13x9 – $45*

Half Sheet (11x17) – $65*

Flavors:

Chocolate Chip

M&M

Brownie

*Price listed is for standard writing and borders. Designs may be extra.

How to Order

Generally, we need at least 24 hours notice for non-custom orders, more for custom orders. The more popular we get, the harder it is to accommodate same-day requests, but you are always welcome to try! Call or text (517) 862-7350 to determine availability. Once we agree on your order and pricing, we will set a time for you to come pick up your goodies. We do our best to make ourselves available on the date and time you prefer. We LOVE seeing old friends and meeting new ones!

How to Pay

Cash is king! In the event you don’t have it handy, we can take payment via:

Venmo friends/family
Check
Credit or debit card. Please add a 3.5% convenience fee.

Housekeeping Notes

Smaller quantities may be occasionally available - watch our Instagram and Facebook stories for these opportunities!
Custom orders or orders over $50 will require prepayment. Thank you for your understanding. We are a small business and can’t afford the risk of people not picking up their orders.
If you are running late to the time we agree upon PLEASE text us at (517) 862-7350 to let us know.
If you are more than an hour late and have not notified us you will forfeit your order and future orders of any size will require prepayment.
The cost for the cookies is based upon dozens fitting into one box. We may occasionally split up your order into several boxes if we deem that to be the best presentation (i.e. we don’t want to smoosh your freshly decorated sugar cookies). If you request to split up your order, there will be a $2 charge for each additional box. Why is this? Boxes aren’t cheap, but we try to keep our prices as low as possible. If everyone asked us to split up orders, we would have to charge more across the board, and we don’t want to do that!

Learn More About